A Study of Issues Relating to the Patentability of Biotechnological Subject Matter: Bibliography

Bibliography

Secondary Sources Consulted

D.J. Abraham, "Shinpo-Sei: Japanese Inventive Step Meets U.S. Non-Obviousness" JPTOS (1995) 528.

K.R. Adamo, "The Power of Suggestion (Teaching, Reason or Motivation) and Combined-Reference Obviousness: Part I" [July/August 1993] Patent World 29.

Application of Abitibi Co. (1982), 62 C.P.R. (2d) 81 (PBA)

B. Ager, "International Bioindustry Forum Agrees Common Patent Position" [Nov. 1991] (No. 122) European Biotechnology Newsletter 5.

C. Arnst, "Life-form Patents Spark Debate in Europe: Is Harvard's Man-made Mouse First Step on Slippery Slope to Patented Human Beings?" The Toronto Star (13 October 1991) B6.

H. Austin, "Biotechnology Patent Law: A European Prospective" (1990) 10(4) The Genetic Engineer and Biotechnologist 15.

S.R. Avisar, "The Ethics of Biotechnology - The Argument in Favour of Patents" (1993) 10 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 209.

R.A. Balk, "New Creations?: Commentary" [January-February 1991] Hastings Centre Report 33.

J.F. Barshear, "Inoculum or Perilous Parasite? Encouraging Genetic Research through Patent Grants: A Call for Regulation and Debate" (1981) 18(2) San Diego Law Review 263.

J.H. Barton, "Patenting Life" (1991) 264(3) Scientific American 40.

T. Beardsley, "Piecemeal Patents: The U.S. Reconsiders Patents on DNA Fragments" (1992) 267(1) Scientific American 106.

B. Belcher and G. Hawtin, "A Patent on Life - Ownership of Plant and Animal Research " (1991) IDRC, Ottawa, Ontario.

S.A. Bent, "Issues and Prospects in the U.S.A. " in W.H. Lesser, ed., Animal Patents: The Legal, Economic and Social Issues (New York: MacMillan, 1989) 5.

B. Berson, "The Taking of Human Tissue for Research and Commerce: A Comparison of U.S. and French Approaches" (1992) 10 Wisconsin International Law Journal 348.

J. Bochnovic, "Invention/Inventive Step/Obviousness" In: "Patent Law of Canada " G.F. Henderson et al. eds. (Carswell: Toronto, 1994) at p. 41

J. Bochnovic, "The Inventive Step" IIC Studies , Volume 5 (Verlag Chemie:Basel, 1982)

W. Booth, "Animals of Invention" (1988)) 240(4853) Science 718.

A.D. Bourassa, "Dans L'Ombre de la Décision Pioneer Hi-Bred" (1993) 10 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 51.

K. Bozicevic, "Patenting DNA - Obviousness Rejections" JPTOS (1992) 753.

J.F. Brashear, "Innocuos Inoculum or Perilous Parasite? Encouraging Genetic Research Through Patent Grants: A Call for Regulation and Debate" (1981) 18 San Diego Law Review 263.

Ronald R. Breaker and Gerald F. Joyce, "Inventing and Improving Ribozyme Function: Rational Design v. Iterative Selection Methods", Trends in Biotechnology Volume 12, 1994 at page 268.

K.R. Britt, "Method of Use Claims in Biotechnology" (1993) 10 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 99.

T.D. Brock and M.T. Madigan, "Biology of Microorganisms", 5th Edition (Prentice Hall: Toronto, 1988).

J. Bronowski, "The Experience of Creation" (1974) 86 Diogenes 94.

R.S. Brown, "The State Role in Regulating Biotechnology" (1988) 17(1) Policy Studies Journal 148.

R.A. Brungs, "Biotechnology and the Control of Life" (1979) 54 Thought 37.

R.A. Brungs, "Biotechnology: A New Reality" (1983) 18 Listening 275.

(1994) 48 BNA's Patent Trademark & Copyright Journal 518.

Budapest Treaty on the International Recognition of the Deposit of Microorganisms (1977).

H.R. Bungay and G. Belfort, "Advanced Biochemical Engineering", John Wiley & Sons: New York, 1987

Bureau of National Affairs [U.S.],"Human Insulin Patent is Invalid for Inadequate Written Description" in BNA's Patent, Trademark & Copyright Journal V. 51 No. 1260 (1996) 354.

Bureau of National Affairs [U.S.],"Biotech Process Claims are not Unpatentable for Obviousness" in BNA's Patent, Trademark & Copyright Journal V. 50 No. 1248 (1995) 677.

Bureau of National Affairs [U.S.],"PTO Assails Bills to Limit Patents on Medical Procedures" in BNA's Patent, Trademark & Copyright Journal V. 50 No. 1250 (1995) 737.

Bureau of National Affairs [U.S.],"Senate Passes Biotech Process Patent Bill" in BNA's Patent, Trademark & Copyright Journal V. 50 No. 1247 (1995) 633.

Bureau of National Affairs [U.S.], "PTO Notice of Biotech Patent Hearings - Notice of Public Hearings and Request for Comments on Patent Protection for Biotechnological Inventions"

Bureau of National Affairs [U.S.], "Biotech Industry Blasts PTO at San Diego Hearing" (1994) 48 BNA's Patent Trademark & Copyright Journal 677.

Bureau of National Affairs [U.S.], "Biotechnology Patent Protection Act Is Subject of House Panel Hearing" (1993) 46 BNA's Patent Trademark & Copyright Journal 141.

Bureau of National Affairs [U.S.], "NIH Gene Patent Application is Debated at Forum on Human Genome" (1992) 44 BNA's Patent Trademark & Copyright Journal 73.

J. Burkhardt, "Biotechnology, Ethics and the Structure of Agriculture" (1988) 5 Agriculture and Human Values 53.

F.H. Buttel and J. Belsky, "Biotechnology, Plant Breeding and Intellectual Property: Social and Ethical Dimensions" (1987) 12(1) Science, Technology & Human Values 31.

J.J. Campbell, "Effects of International Trends & Agreements on Biotechnology Patenting" (1993) 10 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 129.

Canadian Biotech News, "First Cloning of Human Telomerase" (1995) CBN Vol. 4, No. 36 at 3.

Canadian Biotech News, ""Suicide Gene" Linked to Heart Attacks" (1995) CBN Vol. 4, No. 19 at 4.

Canadian Biotech News, "Gene Linked to Alzheimer's Disease Discovered on Chromosome 1" (1995) CBN Vol. 4, No. 33 at 3.

Canadian Biotech News, "EPA Approves Bt for Use in Field Corn" (1995) CBN Vol. 4, No. 33 at 4.

Canadian Biotech News, "Transgenic Plant Field Tests Under Way" (1995) CBN Vol. 4, No. 29 at 6.

B.C. Cannon, "Toward a Clear Standard of Obviousness for Biotechnology Patents" [1994] Cornell Law Review 735.

J. Carey et al., "The Gene Kings" [May 8, 1995] Business Week 72.

J.K. Carton, "The Fate of Patenting Hybridomas and Monoclonal Antibodies in Canada" (1993) 10 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 35.

A. Chamberlain, "Ottawa Promises Easier Biotech Rules" The Toronto Star (25 May 1994) C2.

Chartered Institute of Patent Agents, C.I.P.A. Guide to the Patents Acts, 3rd ed. (London: Sweet & Maxwell, 1994)

Chartered Institute of Patent Agents, European Patents Handbook, Chapter 18, Biological Inventions (London: Longman Professional, releases up to and including 1995).

D.S. Chisum, "Patenting Living Subject Matter, DNA sequences encoding proteins, Gene Therapy and Therapeutic Methods under United States Law " presented at "Patenting Living Organisms Including Human Genes" (AIPPI), Montreal, June 2, 1995.

S. Chong, "The Relevancy of Ethical Concerns in the Patenting of Life Forms" (1993) 10 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 189.

J-M. Claydon, "The Question of Obviousness in the Windsurfers Decision" [1985] 8 EIPR 218.

A. Coghlan, "Pruned Patent Sets Precedent" [4 March 1995] New Scientist 5.

H.D. Coleman, "Protecting Non-U.S. Research in the United States" (1988) 6(7) Bio/Technology 791.

C. Collard, "Limited Protection for Proteins" (1993) 10/1 CIPR 25.

Colombia Law Review, "On the complex Economics of Patent Scope" v. 9E: 839, (1990)

J.G. Colombo, "Reverse Engineering and Process patents: When Is the Process Disclosed" (1991) 7 I.P.J. 85.

Concise Oxford Dictionary, (Clarendon Press: Oxford, 1985)

R.B. Coolley, "The Status of Obviousness and How to Assert it as a Defence" [August 1994] JPTOS 625.

I.P. Cooper, Biotechnology in the Law - 1995 Revision, vol. 1 (New York: Clark, Bordman, Callaghan, 1995)

G. Cope, "Bugs, Bugs, Bugs...: Scientists Busy Putting Bacteria to Work in Industry" The Calgary Herald (22 August 1992) C6.

E. Corcoran, "Charlotte's Patent: Spider Webs and Other Proteins Inspire Engineers" (1992) 266(4) Scientific American 138,140.

C.M. Correa, "Biological Resources and Intellectual Property Rights" [1992] 5 EIPR 154.

G.B. Cox et al., "Patentability of Biotechnological Inventions in Countries of the Pacific Rim" (1994) 4(5) Australasian Biotechnology 274.

P.A. Cox and M.J. Balick, "The Ethnobiotanical Approach to Drug Discovery" (1994) Scientific American June 82.

R. Stephen Crespi, "The European Biotechnology Patent Directive is Dead", Trends in Biotechnology Volume 13 No. 5 at 162, 1995

R.S. Crespi, "The Micro-Organism Deposit System in European Patent Law - An Appraisal of Current Proposals" (1993) 24(1) IIC 1.

R. Stephen Crespi, "Part 1: Patenting in Biotechnology" Trends in Biotechnology Volume 9 at 117, 1991

R.S. Crespi, "Patents and Plant Variety Rights: Is There an Interface Problem? " (1992) 23(2) IIC 168.

R.S. Crespi, "Patents: A Basic Guide to Patenting Biotechnology" (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988) c. 8.

B. Crosariol, "The Wait for Plant Patents: Will Biotech Investors Stay Loyal Long Enough to Reap a Harvest?" (1990) 78(42) Financial Times 8.

J. Cubert, "U.S. Patent Policy and Biotechnology: Growing Pains on the Cutting Edge" (1995) 77(2) JPTOS 151.

A. Cunningham, "Getting the Game Right: Some Plain Words on the Identity and Invention of Science" (1988) 19(3) Stud. Hist. Phil. Sci. 365.

E. Daniell, "Polymerase Chain Reaction: Development of a Novel Technology in a Corporate Environment" In: Biotechnology: The Science and The business, Ed V. Moses and Re. Cape (Harwood Academic Publishers: New York, 1991) Chapter 11 at 147.

K.E. Davies, "Genome Analysis: A Practical Approach", IRL Press: Washington, 1988.

A.W. Deller, Deller's Walker on Patents, vol. 1, 2nd ed. (New York: Baker, Voorhis, 1964) c. 1.

H.G. DeYoung, "Biotech Companies and Drug Firms Take Steps to Combat Drug-Resistant Bacteria" (1994) 14(13) Genetic Engineering News 1.

V. DiCerbo, "The Patentability of Animals " (1993) 24 IIC 788.

H. D'Iorio and J. A. Erratt, "Plant Breeders' Rights - Practical Considerations" (1995) 11 C.I.P.R. 277.

S. Donnelley et al., "The Brave New World of Animal Biotechnology" (1994) 24 Special Supplement Hasting Center Report S1 - S31 .

H.S. Duncan, "Canadian Biotechnology Patent - An Industry Perspective" (1993) 10 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 347.

R.E. Dimock "Patent Anticipation of What's New, Patent Act" In: Patent Law of Canada Eds. G.F. Henderson et al. (Carswell: Toronto, 1994) at 101.

K. Drlica, "Understanding DNA and Gene Cloning: A Guide for the Curious" (John Wiley & sons, Inc.: Toronto, 1992.

K.M. Ebert, "Prospective Developments in Laboratory Animals" in W.H. Lesser, ed., Animal Patents: The Legal, Economic and Social Issues (New York: MacMillan, 1989) 61.

R.S. Eisenberg, "Proprietary Rights and the Norms of Science in Biotechnology Research" (1987) 97(2) Yale Law Journal 177.

European Patent Office, "Case Law of the Boards of Appeal of the European Patent Office - 1987-1992" E.P.O. (1993)

European Patent Office, "Guidelines for Examination in the European Patent Office" E.P.O. (1994)

F. Farfan, "Patentability of Life Forms" (1988) 5(12) Canadian Computer Law Reporter 138.

"Federal Study Urges Patent Protection for New Microbes" The Toronto Star (25 November 1991) B8.

K. Finney, "Inventions in Biotechnology and the Assessment of Obviousness" (1994) 4(5) Australasian Bio-Technology 280.

B. Fleisher, "Forces Shaping The Agricultural Biotechnology Industry: Patents, Insurance, Regulation and Financing" (1988) 17(1) Policies Studies Journal 169.

M.J. Flower, "Taking DNA to Market and Regulatory Default" (1981) 3(2) Bioethics Quart. , 112.

R.H. Foote, "The Technology and Costs of Deposits" in W.H. Lesser, ed., Animal Patents: The Legal, Economic and Social Issues (New York: MacMillan, 1989).

H. Fox, "The Canadian Law and Practice relating to Letters Patent for Inventions", 4th ed. (Toronto: Carswell, 1969).

J.L. Fox, "The Ethical Roar of Germ-Line Gene Therapy" (1995) 13 Bio/Technology 18.

C.A. Franklin, "Modern Biotechnology: A Review of Current Regulatory Status and Identification of Research and Regulatory Needs" (1988) 4 Toxicology and Industrial Health 91.

M. Fritz, "Patently Absurd: Cornering Crops Without Leaving The Lab" Halifax Chronicle-Herald (28 November 1994) A8.

J. Galloway, "Does Human Genome Mapping Mean Business?" [February 1992] Scrip Magazine 26.

S.M. Gendel et al., eds., Agricultural Bioethics: Implications of Agricultural Biotechnology (Ames, IA: Iowa State University Press, 1990).

"Genentech Calls for USTR Action on Japan" [24 February 1995] (no. 2002) Scrip Magazine 18.

P. Gillman, "Transgenics - Brave New World or Cloudy Future?" [March 1994] Scrip Magazine 18.

A. Gore, "Planning a New Biotechnology Policy" (1991) 5 Harvard Journal of Law and Technology 19.

R. Gosain, "Church Objects to Patent Protection for Biotechnology; Collor's Problems Hold Up Draft of New Patent Law Bill" [October 1992] Patent World 7.

G. Gransden, "Canada Patently Absurd, Says Biotech Research" The [Toronto] Globe & Mail (14 August 1990) B20.

M. Gravelle, "Patent Considerations for the Biotechnology Industry" (1990) 4(8) New Biotech 21.

M.L. Gravelle, "Biotechnology - An Overview", CIPR, Volume 10, 1993, pages 1-10.

M. S. Greenfield, "Recombinant DNA Technology: A Science Struggling with the Patent Law" Stanford Law Review 44:1052 (1992).

W. Greenberg and D. Kamin, "Property Rights and Payment to Patients for Cell Lines Derived from Human Tissues: An Economic Analysis" (1993) 36 Soc. Sci. Med. 1071.

L. Gronning-Nielsen, "Concept of Novelty " (1991) 22 IIC 929.

P.W. Grubb, "Patents in Biotechnology" (1986) 4(b) Swiss Biotech 12.

C. Gugerell, "Bio-technology patenting - the current practice of the European Patent Office" (1994) 14(3) The Genetic Engineer and Biotechnologist 195.

J.W. Haefele, Creativity and Innovation (New York: Rienhold, 1962).

N.D. Hamilton, "Who Owns Dinner: Evolving Legal Mechanisms for Ownership of Plant Genetic Resources" (1993) 28 Tulsa Law Journal 587.

W. Hansel, "Prospective Developments in Animal Agriculture" in W.H. Lesser, ed., Animal Patents: The Legal, Economic and Social Issues (New York: MacMillan, 1989) 70.

D. Hansen, "New Rules Ease Biotech Patent Requirements" (1995) 73(1) Chemical and Engineering News 7.

T.S. Harding, "Exploitation of the Creators" (1941) 8 Phil. Sci. 385.

M.S. Hart, "Getting Back to Basics: Reinventing Patent Law for Economic Efficiency" (1994) 8 I.P.J. 217.

S. Hassler, "European Patent Legislation: A Missed Opportunity" (1995) 13(4) Bio/Technology 305.

W.L. Hayhurst, "The Art of Claiming and Reading a Claim" In: Henderson, G.G., et al., eds. "Patent Law of Canada" (Toronto: Carswell, 994) at 195.

W.L. Hayhurst, "Exclusive Rights in Relation to Living Things" (1991) 6 I.P.J. 171.

G.F. Henderson et. al. eds "Patent Law of Canada" (Carswell: Toronto, 1994).

J.E. Hobbs et al., "Friend or Foe? - Farmer Perceptions of Biotechnology" (1990) 38 Can. J. Agric. Econ. 1005.

R.T. Hughes and J.H. Woodley, "Hughes and Woodley on Patents" issue 1995 (Markham:Butterworths, 1984-1995) at §11

"ICI Challenges Calgene Plant Antisense Patent" (1992) 12(8) Genetic Technology News 6.

Japanese Patent Office, Examination Guidelines for Patent and Utility Model in Japan (Tokyo: Aippi-Japan, 1994) c.2,3.

C. Joyce,"Prospectors for Tropical Medicines" (1991) New Scientist October 19, at 36-40.

I. Judge et al., "Chiron v. Organon and Biogen v. Medeva: A Boost for the Biotech Industry" [December 1993/January 1994] Patent World 20.

A. Kahn, "Breveter la connaissance" [July-August 1992] (N^o 114) Biofutur 18.

K.T. Kaminski, "Disclosure of Information in a Computer-Readable Form for Biotechnology Inventions" (1993) 10 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 93.

I. Karet, "Priority and Sufficiency, Inventions and Obviousness - UK Court of Appeal Decision in Biogen v Medeva" [1995] 1 EIPR 42.

R. Kimura, "Ethics Committees for Hi-Tech Innovations in Japan" (1989) 14 Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 457.

D. King, "Regulation of Biotechnology a Sea of Problems, Scott Says" The [Toronto] Globe and Mail (8 August 1988) A12.

B.G. Kingwell, "Functional Language and Fingerprints" (1993) 10 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 87.

U. Kinkeldey, "The Patenting of Animals " (1993) 24(6) IIC 777.

A.D. Kline, "We Have Not Yet Identified the Heart of the Moral Issues in Agricultural Biotechnology", (1991) 4(2) Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 216.

B. Kneen, "The Privatization of Life" [Toronto] Catholic New Times (7 November 1993) 9.

G. Knesch, "Assessing Inventive Step in Examination and Opposition Proceedings in the EPO" (1994) 3 EPI Information 95.

Y. Ko, "An Economic Analysis of Biotechnology Patent Protection" (1992) 102 Yale Law Journal 777.

A. Koestler, Insight and Outlook: An Inquiry into the Common Foundations of Science, Art and Social Ethics (New York: MacMillan, 1949).

L.M. Kurdydyk and S.S. McDiarmid, "Patent Infringement Issues relating to Biotechnology" (1993) 10 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 175.

P. Lançon, "What's Happening in Europe" [January 1990] Patent World 39.

L. Laudan, "Invention and Justification" (1983) 50 Philosophy of Science 320.

R. Lawrence, "Procedures and Pitfalls in Patent Protection" in Biotech 83: Proceedings of the International Conference on the Commercial Applications and Implications of Biotechnology (Northwood, UK: Online Publications, 1983)

W. Lesser, "Royalty Collection for Patented Livestock" (1994) 10 European Intellectual Property Review 441.

W. Lesser, The report of the committee on Judiciary: Staff Report of the sub-committee on Courts, Civil Liberties and the Administration of Justice Accompanying the Transgenic Animal Patent Reform Act report 100-88 of the House of Representatives, 100th Congress 2nd session. Dated August 26, 1899 in: "Animal patents: The legal, economic and social issues ", MacMillan Publishers Limited: New York, 1989, pages 185-209.

S.A. Levin and M.A. Harwell, "Potential Ecological Consequences of Genetically Engineered Organisms" (1986) 10(4) Environ. Management 495.

M. Litman, Obvious Process Rejections Under 35 U.S.C. 103" JPTOS (1989) 775.

M. Llewelyn, "Industrial Applicability/Utility and Genetic Engineering: Current Practices in Europe and the United States" [1994] EIPR 473.

F.M. Lynn et al., "The Interplay of Science, Technology, and Values in Environmental Applications of Biotechnology" (1988) 17(1) Policy Studies Journal 109.

H.A. Macdonald, "The Human Genome Product - Is Canada Ready to Join the World's Ultimate Biological Megaproject?" (1990) 4 New Biotech 20.

D.W. MacKinnon, In Search of Human Effectiveness (Buffalo: Creative Education Foundation, 1978)

S.B. Maebius, "Biotech Transfers: From Bailing Mice to Selling Hybridomas" [August 1994] JPTOS 601.

R. Magnaval, "New Biotechnologies - A Financial Venture Without Industrial Strategy" (1988) 8(6) Industrial Biotechnology 34.

L. Maher, "The Patent Environment: Domestic and European Community Frameworks for Biotechnology" (1992) 33 Jurimetrics Journal 67.

Manual of Patent Office Procedure (MOPOP) Ottawa-Hull, 1990.

R.W. Marusyk, "The Patentability of New Plant Life Forms in Canada" (1990) 16 Can. Bus. L.J. 333.

K.J. McGough, "Defining The Scope of Biotech Patent Claims" (1995) 13 Bio/Technology 318.

K.N. McKerghan, "The Nonobviousness of Inventions: In Search of a Functional Standard"

(1991) Wash. L. Rev. v. 66 1061.

R. McLaughlin, "Invention and Induction: Laudan, Simon and the Logic of Discovery" (1982) 49 Philosophy of Science 198.

E. McMahon, "Nucleic Acid Sequences and Other Naturally Occurring Products: Are They Patentable in Canada?" (1993) 10 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 11.

T. Messer, "Principles Balance Biotech Pros and Cons" (1993) 107(2) Canadian Grocer 10.

J. Middlemiss, "Ethics, The Law and Genetic Engineering" (1993) 17(1) Can. Law. 41.

D. Mieth, "Theological and Ethical Reflections on Bioethics", in D. Mieth and J. Pohier eds., Ethics in the Natural Sciences (Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1989) 26.

G. Miller, "Owning Biotechnological Invention: Is There A Difference Between Animate and Inanimate Property?" (1993) XV(2) The Liverpool Law Review 143.

L.W. Miller, "Mathematics: Discovery or Invention--Or Making Explicit" (1976) 25 Tulane Studies in Philosophy 41

R. Milligan and W. Lesser, "Implications for Agriculture" in W.H. Lesser, ed., Animal Patents: The Legal, Economic and Social Issues (New York: MacMillan, 1989) 100.

P.R. Moony, "Profiteering from the Wisdom of the South" (1994- February) Worldbusiness 25.

J. Morrow, "Biotechnology Licensing" (1993) 10 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 277.

J. Morrow, "Plant Breeders' Rights - An International Perspective" (1992) 9 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 34.

J.D. Morrow, "Applications of Patent Law to Biotechnology Subject Matter" (1989) 6 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 33.

J. Morton, "Pharmaceutical Patents and Bill C-91: The Historical Perspective: C.I.P.R. 10(1) 145 (1993).

V. Moses and R.E. Cape, "Biotechnology: The Science and The Business", Harwood Academic Publishers: New York, 1991.

R. Moufang, "Patenting of Human Genes, Cells and Parts of the Body? - The Ethical Dimensions of Patent Law" (1994) 25(4) IIC 487.

R. Moufang, "Methods of Medical Treatment under Patent Law" (1993) 24(1) IIC 18.

R. Moufang, "Protection for Plant Breeding and Plant Varieties - A Frontier of Patent Law" (1992) 23 IIC 328.

M. Moynihan, "The European Biotech Directive - an End in Sight" [April 1994] Patent World 24.

M. Munro, "Bovine Biotechnology Moo-ving too Fast for the Industry" The Vancouver Sun (26 January 1994) C4.

M. Munro, "From Test Tube to table: Now That Science Has Created the Genetically Engineered Tomato, Is Biotechnology Unleashing a Monster into Our Food System?" The Vancouver Sun (26 January 1994) C5.

National Biotechnology Advisory Committee, Fifth Report: National Biotechnology Business Strategy: Capturing Competitive Advantage for Canada, (Ottawa: Supply and Services, Canada, November 1991) (Chairperson: W.A. Cochrane).

S. Newman and N. Wilker, "The CRG Says No to Patenting Life Forms" (1992) 8(2) Gene Watch 8.

T.I. Nguti, "Patent Law: Doctrinal Stability - A Research and Development Definition of Invention is Key" (1986) 20 Val. U.L. Rev. 52.

R. Nott, "The European Biotech Directive - An End in Sight? (Reprise)" [September 1994] Patent World 5.

R. Nott, "Plants and Animals: Why They Should be Protected by Patents and Variety Rights" [July/August 1993] Patent World 45.

W.D. Noonan, "Patenting Medical and Surgical Procedures" (1995) JPTOS vol. 77 no. 8 651.

D. Novak, "Bioethics and the Contemporary Jewish Community" (1990) 20(4) Hastings Centre Report (Supplement) 14.

K.W. O'Connor, "Congressional Perspectives" in W.H. Lesser, ed., Animal Patents: The Legal, Economic and Social Issues (New York: MacMillan, 1989).

S. Okuyama, 1994 Amendment to the Patent Law and Related Laws in Japan (Okuyama & Co., Tokyo, April 1995) [unpublished].

S. Okuyama, Examination Practice for Chemical and Biotechnological Inventions in Japan (Okuyama & Co., Tokyo, December 1994) [unpublished].

R.W. Old and S.B. Primrose, "Principles of Gene Manipulation: An Introduction to Genetic Engineering" Fifth Ed. (Oxford: Blackwell Scientific Publications, 1994), Chapter 1.

T. Oredsson, "Biological Inventions and Swedish Patent Legislation (Part I)" (1988), 70 J.P.T.O.S. 287.

T. Oredsson, "Biological Inventions and Swedish Patent Legislation (Part II)" (1988), 70 J.P.T.O.S. 357.

"Organibio: bilan et perspectives" [April, 1992] (N^o 111) Biofutur 39-40.

T. Orlhac, "Les Specificites de L'Invention dans le Domaine de la Biotechnologie" (1993) 10 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 57.

H.R. Pappu, C. Nllniblett and R.F. Lee, "Application of Recombinant DNA Technology to Plant Protection: Molecular Approaches in Engineering v. Resistance in Crop Plants", World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnology Volume 11 at 426 (1995).

M. Paver, "All Animals Are Patentable, But Some Are More Patentable Than Others" [March 1992] Patent World 9.

M. Paver, "A Tale of Two Rodents, or A Rodent with Two Tails: Europe Grapples with Patenting Animals" [June 1993] Patent World 29.

D.C.L. Perkins, "Intellectual Property Protection for Biotechnology" in Biotech 83: Proceedings of the International Conference on the Commercial Applications and Implications of Biotechnology (Northwood, UK: Online Publications, 1983)

R. Perry, "What is a Patentable Biotechnological Invention?" in The World Biotech Report 1984, Vol. 1: Europe (The Proceedings of Biotech '84 Europe) (Northwood, UK: Online Publications, 1984) 45.

S. Pfürtner, "The responsibilities of Science: An Approach to Professional Ethics" in D. Mieth and J. Pohier, eds., Ethics in the Natural Sciences, (Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1989), 63.

D. Pimentel, "Genetic Engineering, Agriculture, and Environmental Policy" (1988) 17(1) Policy Studies Journal 117.

L.C. Plein and D.J. Webber, "Congressional Consideration of Biotechnology" (1988) 17(1) Policy Studies Journal 136.

M.J. Plotkin, "The Healing Forest" (1990) The Futurist January-February, at 9-14.

K.R. Popper, The Logic of Scientific Discovery (New York: Basic Books, 1961)

S.C. Price, "The Economic Impact of Novel Genes in Plant Biotechnology: Not Without Strong Intellectual Property Rights" in Conservation of Plant Genes (New York: Academic Press, 1992) 45.

S.C. Price and L.M. Lamola, "Decision Points for Transferring Plant Intellectual Property to the Private Sector" in R.P. Adams, et al., eds., Conservation of Plant Genes II: Utilization of Ancient and Modern DNA, vol. 48 (Missouri Botanical Garden, 1994).

"Proposals for Regulating Biotechnology" (1988) 40(2) Canadian Chemical News 9.

J.B. Prowda, "Moore v. The Reagents of the University of California: An Ethical Debate on Informed Consent and Property Rights in a Patient's Cells" (1995) J.P.T.O.S. 611.

P.A. Rae, "Patentability of Living Subject Matter" (1993) 10 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 41.

"Research Mouse Patented" The Calgary Herald (26 December 1992) B7.

P.A. Rauh and H-R Jaenichen, "Novelty and Inventive Step in Inventions having Proteins or DNA Sequences as their Subject Matter" JPTOS (1988) 313.

B.C. Reid, "Biogen in the EPO: The Advantage of Scientific Understanding" [1995] 2 EIPR 98.

R.J. Roberts, "Patenting of Animals: The Ex Parte Allen Case" (1988) 14 Review of International Business Law 419.

T. Roberts, "Broad Claims for Biotechnological Inventions: Opinion" EIPR; v. 9: 371 (1994).

J.C. Robinson, "Canadian Disclosure Requirements for Biotechnology Inventions" (1993) 10 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 69.

J.R. Rudolph, "Regulation of the Products of Biotechnology Under the Canadian Environment Protection Act: Any Impetus for Innovation?" (1993) 10 C.I.P.R. 317.

R. Saliwanchik, "Biotechnology Patent Law in the United States of America" (1990) 10(3) Genetic Engineer and Biotechnologist 13.

J. Savina, "The Patentability of the Second Therapeutic Application - Why Must the Law be Changed?" (1993) I.P. World 26.

P. Schmitz, "An Ethical Look at Agricultural Biotechnology" in D. Mieth and J. Pohier, eds., Ethics in the Natural Sciences (Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1989) 127.

Science Council of Canada, Seeds of Renewal Biotechnology and Canada's Resource Industries (Summary of Report 38) (Ottawa-Hull: Queen's Printer, 1985).

Science Council of Canada, Seeds of Renewal Biotechnology and Canada's Resource Industries (Report 38) (Ottawa-Hull: Queen's Printer, 1985).

J.M. Sedivy and A.L. Joyner, "Gene Targeting" (W.H. Freeman and Company: New York, New York, 1992).

R. Seltzer, "First Transgenic Bull Sires Transgenic Calves" Chemical and Engineering News (14 February 1994) 30.

R.M. Sherwood, "Intellectual Property and Economic Development" (Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1990).

L. Sisson, "Plant Breeders' Rights Legislation for Canada" (1992) 9 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 38.

A.A. Sorensen, "Prospectives of Farms" in W.H. Lesser, ed., Animal Patents: The Legal, Economic and Social Issues (New York: MacMillan, 1989) 117.

S. Stinson, "New rules ease bio-tech patent requirements". Chem. & Eng. News, January 1995, p.7-8 (Utility) (1995)

D.M. Stotland, "Is Biotechnology Patentable in Canada?" (1991) 9 Canadian Intellectual Property Review 1.

J. Straus, "The Development and Status of European Law" in W.H. Lesser, ed., Animal Patents: The Legal, Economic and Social Issues, (New York: MacMillan, 1989) 16.

M. Suzuki, S.A. Branner, M. Gerstein and N. Yagi, "DNA Recognition Code of Transcription Factors", Protein Engineering Volume 8, page 319 (1995).

G.S.A. Szabo, "The Problem and Solution Approach to the Inventive Step" [1986] 10 EIPR 293.

J. Thurston, "Recent EC Developments in Biotechnology" [1993] 6 EIPR 187.

E. Turrini, "The Concept of Novelty - Our View of the Caselaw of the Boards of Appeal of the European Patent Office" (1991) 22 IIC 932.

Trademark & Copyright Journal, "Senate Passes Biotech Process Patent Bill" BNA's Patent (1995) vol. 50 at 633.

M.D. Trevan et al., "Biotechnology: The Biological Principals" Taylor and Francis: New York, 1987.

United States Trademark and Patent Office, "In the Matter of: Public Hearing on the Standard of Non-obviousness" held Wednesday, July 20, 1994.

M.A. Valiante and R.P. Muldoon "Biotechnology and the Environment: A Regulatory Proposal" (1985) 23 Osgoode hall L.J. 359 at 364-365.

A.C. Varga, "Playing God": The Ethics of Biotechnical Intervention" (1995) 60 Thought 181.

M. Vicente, "Introduction: A Simple Expression? Complexities of Genetic Regulation in Micro-organisms", World Journal of Microbiology and Biotechnoloy Volume 9 401 (1993).

A.S. Viksnins, "Amgen, Inc. v. United States International Trade Commission: Designer Genes Don't Fit" (1991) 76 Minnesota Law Review 161.

N. Wade, "Biotechnology and Its Public" (1984) 6(1) Technology In Society 17.

H. Wegner and E. Katayama, "Biotech Japan" [January 1990] Patent World 26.

H.C. Wegner, "Much Ado about Durden" (1989) J.P.T.O.S. 785.

M.S. Weiner, "Biotechnological Inventions: What Really Can Be Patented Under Current Law?" [August 1989] Chemtech 467.

A.J. Wells, "Patenting New Life Forms: An Ecological Perspective" (1994) 3 EIPR 111.

D.C. Wertz, "Ethical and Legal Implications of the New Genetics: Issues for Discussion" (1992) 35(4) Soc. Sci. Med. 495.

L. Westra, "A Transgenic Dinner? Social and Ethical Issues in Biotechnology and Agriculture" (1993) 24(3) Journal of Social Philosophy 215.

R. Whaite and N. Jones, "Biotechnological Patents in Europe - The Draft Directive" [1989] 5 EIPR 145.

M.E. Wheeler, "Patenting in the Biotechnology Field" (1987) 3 P.T.I.C. Review 2

E. Williamson, "The Linguistic Basis of Patent Law" (1943) 25 J.P.O.S. 852 at 869.

J.F. Witherspoon, ed., "Nonobviousness-The Ultimate Condition of Patentability" (Washington: The Bureau of National Affairs Inc., 1978).

M.D. Yablonsky and W.J. Hone, "Patenting DNA Sequences" (1995) BIO/Technology v. 13 656.

S. Yellin, "Biotech Industries Booming: Biology Used to Produce New Products in Everything From Medicine and Agriculture to Natural Resources" Halifax Chronicle-Herald (23 May 1994) B16.

S. Yellin, "Cut Regulations on Biotechnology Industry - Report" Halifax Chronicle-Herald (19 May 1994) D9.

H. Yiang-Shan, "Within the Great Wall: Chinese Biotechnology" (1991) 11(4) Genetic Engineer and Biotechnologist 25.

T. Zeleny, "Property Rights in Living Things: Difficulties with Reproduction and Infringement" (1994) 2 San Diego Justice Journal 209.

W. Zimmerli, "Is the Technologisation of Nature Ethical", in D. Mieth and J. Pohier (eds)., Ethics in the Natural Sciences (Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1989) 138.

Zimmerman, S.B. and Vienken, J. (1983) "Electric field induced cell to cell fusion" J. Membr. Biol. 67: 165-82.

P. Zurer, "Flaws Cited in NIH Gene Patent Application" Chemical and Engineering News (26 October 1992) 17.

Cases

Application of Abitibi Company (1982), 62 CPR (2d) 81 (PAB).

Ex Parte Allen 2 USPQ (2D) 1425 (1987).

Amgen Inc. v. Chugai Pharmaceutical Co. Ltd. 927 F.2d 1200 (Fed. Cir.) (1991).

Beecham Canada Ltd. v. Procter & Gamble Co. (1982), 61 C.P.R. (2d) (F.C.A.).

In Re Bell (90991 F.2d 781 (Fed. Cir. 1993).

Beloit Canada Ltd. v. Valmet OY (1986) 8 C.P.R. (3d) 289.

In re Bergy (1979), 201 U.S.P.Q. 352 (C.C.P.A.).

Biogen v. International Murex Technologies Corporation (28 July 1994), European Patent Office (Technical Appeal Board) T 0296/93 - 3.3.4

Biogen Inc. v. Medev Plc [1995] R.P.C. 25 (C.A.).

Canadian Gypsum Co. v. Gypsum, Lime & Alabastine Can. Ltd. [1931] Ex.C.R.180.

Canadian Radio Patents Ltd. v. Hobbs Hardware Co., [1929] Ex. C.R.238.

In Re Chilowsky 108 U.S.P.Q. 1956 (C.C.P.A.).

Chipman Chemicals Ltd. v. Fairview Chemical Co. [1932] Ex. C.R.107.

CIBA-GEIGY AG Basel, 3/1984 Official Journal EPO 112 (Technical Board of Appeal).

Commissioner of Patents v. CIBA Ltd. (1959) 30 C.P.R. 335 (S.C.C.).

Re Application of Compagnies Reunies des Glaces & Verres, (1931), 48 R.P.C. 185.

Re: Application for Patent of Connaught Laboratories (1982), 82 CPR (2d) 32.

Consolboard Inc. v. MacMillian Bloedel (Saskatchewan) Ltd. (1981), 56 C.P.R. (2d) 145 (S.C.C.).

Continental Soya Co. Ltd. v. J.R. Short Milling Co. Ltd. (1943), 2 C.P.R. 1 (S.C.C.).

Crosley Radio v. G. 193 Ex.C.R.190 at 197.

Diamond v. Chakrabarty (1980) 447 U.S. 303.

Diamond v. Chakrabarty (1980), 206 U.S.P.Q. 193.

Ex Parte Deuel 34 U.S.P.Q. 2d 1210.

Electric Fireproofing Co. of Can. v. Electric Fireproofing Co. (1909), 43 S.C.R. 182.

Re Gazave 154 U.S.P.Q. 92 (C.C.P.A. 1967)

Genetech Inc., (1989) T 292/85 (Decision of Technical Board of Appeal 3.3.2).

Genetech Inc.'s Patent, [1989] R.P.C. 147 (C.A.).

Genetech Inc. v. Welcome Foundation, Ltd., 14 U.S.P.Q. 2d 1363 (P.N.A.).

Gerrard Wire Tying Machines Co. v. Cary Manufacturing Co. [1926] Ex. C.R. 170

Graham v. John Deere 383 U.S. 1 (1966) (U.S.S.C.).

Grant of European patent No. 0 169 672 (Onco-mouse/Harvard) (1992) Official Journal EPO v. 10 588.

Gris Singer v. Victor Talking Machine, [1929] Ex.C.R.24.

Ex Parte Hibberd 227 USPQ 43 (1985).

Hoecht v. Halocarbon (1983), 74 C.P.R. (2d) 95 at 99 (F.C.T.D.).

Faberwerke Hoecht A.G. v. Halocarbon (Ontario) Ltd. (1970), 42 C.P.R. (2d) 145 at 155 (S.C.C.).

Hoffman-LaRoche v. Commissioner of Patents (1955), 23 C.P.R. 1 (S.C.C.).

Hosiers Ltd. v. Penmans Ltd. [1925] Ex.C.R.93.

Johns-Manville Corporation's Patent [1967] R.P.C. 479.

Lawson v. Commissioner of Patents (1970), 62 C.P.R. 101 (Ex. Ch.).

Lubrizol Genetics Inc., 3/1990 Official Journal EPO 71 (Technical Board of Appeal).

In Re May & Baker & Ciba Ltd. (1948), 65 R.P.C. 255.

Metalliflex Ltd. v. Rodi & Wienenberger A.G. (1969), 35 C.P.R. 49 (S.C.C.).

Monsanto Co. v. Commissioner of Patents (1979), 42 C.P.R. (2d) 161 (S.C.C.).

Morgan v. Seward(1837), 1 Web. Pat. Cas. 187.

Olin Mathieson Chemical Corporation v. Biorex Laboratories [1970] R.P.C. 157.

Onco-mouse/Harvard (1990) T 19/90 (Decision of Technical Board of Appeal 3.3.2).

Application of Pallos (1978), 1 C.P.R. 93d) 334.

Pioneer Hi-bred Ltd. v. Commissioner of Patents, (1989), 25 C.P.R. (3d) 257 (S.C.C.).

Pioneer Hi-bred Ltd. v. Commissioner of Patents (1987), 14 C.P.R. (3d) 491.

Procter & Gamble v. Kimberly-Clark Ltd., (1991) 40 C.P.R. (3d) 1 (F.C.T.D.).

Raytheon Co. v. Roper Corp. 220 U.S.P. Q. 592 (Fed. Cir. )(1983).

Reading & Bates Construction Co. v. Baker Resources Corp. (1987), 18 C.P.R. (3d) 181 (F.C.A.).

Re Application No. 086,556 (1975), C.P.R. (2d) 56 (PAB).

Reeves Brothers case (1978), 43 C.P.R. (2nd) 145 (Fed. T.D.).

Reynolds v. Herbert Smith & Co., Ltd. (1902), 20 R.P.C. 123 (Ch. D.).

Rubbermaid (Canada) Ltd. v. Tucker Plastic Products Ltd. (1972), 8 C.P.R. (2d) 6 (F.C.T.D.).

Sharpe & Dohme Inc. v. Boots Pure Drug Coy Ld. (1928), 45 R.P.C. 153.

Shell Oil Co. v. Commissioner of Patents (1982), 67 C.P.R. (2d) 1 (S.C.C.).

Stiftung v. Renishaw PLC 20 U.S.P.Q. 2d 1094 (Fed. Cir.)(1991).

Tennessee Eastman v. The Commissioner of Patents, [1974] S.C.R. 111; (1972), 8 C.P.R. (2d) 202 (S.C.C.).

Tye-Sil (1991), 35 C.P.R. (3rd) 350 at 361 (Fed. C.A.).

Unipak Cartons Ltd. v. Crown Zellerbach Canada Ltd. (1960), 20 Fox Pat.C. 1 (Ex. Ct)

Re Application for Patent of Wayne State University (1988), 22 C.P.R. (3d) 407 (PBA).

Western Electric Co. et al. v. Baldwin Int'l Radio of Canada Ltd., [1934] S.C.R. 570.

Windsurfing International Inc. v. Tabur Marine (Great Britain) Ltd. (1984), [1985] 4 R.P.C. 59 (C.A.).

Xerox of Canada Ltd. v. IBM Canada Ltd. (1977), 33 C.P.R. (2d) 24